10 Seconds: Matthew Herbert
1. Miles Davis - Springsville (2'10" - 2'20")
from Miles Davis - Miles Ahead (1957)
“I feel this Miles album doesn’t get as much love as it deserves. The Gil Evans arrangements are so fluid and elegant. The whole thing is effortless, and you can sing along to so many of the band's lines. I feel like we should start an instrumental jazz karaoke night so nerds can sing along to instrumental songs like this.
Miles’s entry after the build at 2:15 is wild. Wrong and strong. One of Miles’s great lessons for us all: you don’t have to get every note right, but you’ve got to get the intention right."
2. Violeta Parra - Arauco Tiene Una Pena (0’27” - 0’37”)
from Violeta Parra - El folklore de Chile según (1962)
"A Chilean icon, and rightly so. At 0:32, she doesn’t change the chord on the downbeat as she does throughout the rest of the song. Instead, she picks up the harmonic shift on the upward motion of the strum on the following beat.
The endless possibilities of digital recording techniques mean that an engineer would, in all likelihood, re-record this passage or edit it to match every other occurrence in the song. But when studio time was expensive and tape even more so, these kinds of variations survived. They amplify our humanness rather than sanitise it. One benefit of AI, if that’s the right way of framing it, is that it may push us to seek out these variations and breaks in the pattern. As my friend at Google says: who wants to watch a robot juggle?
3. Gustav Mahler - 10th Symphony Adagio (19'10" - 19'20")
“It’s unfinished, so we’ll never quite know how he might have developed it, but at 19:15 he stacks nine of the twelve notes of the Western chromatic scale on top of one another. Three more and he’d have all of them sounding at once. (And he’d have beaten serialism to it.)
It’s a huge burst of modernism for 1910. What I like, though, is how he almost immediately backs away from the enormity and intensity of the chord, as if disowning it or being slightly shocked by what he’s just done. Then there’s a long, extended suspension right to the end that seems almost to ignore what has just happened."
4. Bjork - Unison (3'35" - 3'45")
from Bjork live at the Royal Opera House (2001)
“Her voice breaks on the word love. It’s already an incredible lyric: “one hand, it loves the other.” The break only deepens the vulnerability. She then pats her chest, as if trying to summon strength back into her voice and body, before going on to soar above the orchestra. I find it deeply moving. It's also one of her most emotional pieces. To me, it feels like a modern hymn."
5. Duke Ellington, Charles Mingus, Max Roach - Fleurette Africaine (0’00” - 0’10”)
from Duke Ellington, Charles Mingus, Max Roach - Money Jungle (1963)
“Another album I love in its entirety, but Mingus is the standout on this track for me, particularly in the first ten seconds. He sets the whole thing up in such a unique way that it becomes impossible to break free from the spell of that opening riff. The commitment from the entire band then carries that strangeness all the way to the end."
6. Todd Terry - Jump Up in the Air (0’00” - 0’10”)
from Todd Terry - Jump Up in the Air (1991)
“As a rural kid who grew up tuning his violin diligently every day, the shock of hearing an out-of-tune sample, and the sort-of-not-quite-traditional harmonic relationships between the samples in the first ten seconds of this killer early house tune, suddenly broke open new worlds for me. Music is just tension and release, and the tuning is doing a lot of the tension here. Todd has a hip-hop approach, of course, and it has the delicious SP1200 crunch to it too. The net effect is hypnotic, unsettling and, to me at least, still intoxicating as it returns again and again to the sample."
7. Marvin Gaye - What's Going On (0'07" - 0'17")
from Marvin Gaye - What's Going On (1971)
"From seven seconds in, the bongo part in the left-hand speaker is sooooooooo loud. (And the finger clicks that come in at 1:15 are also super loud before dropping out and then returning really loud again later.) For a while, I found it hard to listen to the track without just listening to the bongos and trying to work out whether they were deliberately that loud or a bit of a mistake. The internet is full of men telling you "how to mix" or which "rules" to follow, and we have presets, AI and all sorts of technological interventions now to make sure that we avoid mixing bongos really loud like that. But I love how nothing can change the fact that these wildly loud bongos are on one of the very best albums of all time, and everyone (including me) accepts them and their purposefulness in the mix. It really is about the sum of the parts."
8. George Benson - Give Me the Night (0’55” – 1’05”)
from George Benson - Give Me the Night (1980)
“I guess everyone knows it, but the backing vocal line at 1:00 is so satisfying. I remember hearing it for the first time and feeling like it was such a joy nugget that I wanted to hear it again and again, always waiting for it to reappear. A great reminder that complexity can exist in surprisingly natural ways inside pop music. Extra points for George, too, for skating backwards at sunset whilst playing guitar at the start of the video."
9. West Side Story - Cool (3’15” – 3’25”)
from Leonard Bernstein - West Side Story OST (1961)
“I love this whole track, and the choreography and the way it's filmed, etc., but the bit that gets me every time is when it suddenly drops into this perky reharmonisation at 3:15, into a major key. It forgets the song is about gang violence for a moment and takes on a kind of surprising jauntiness that implicates the whole band in its swing. I always feel like it's Bernstein just giving himself a couple of bars to enjoy himself without having to serve the story, or anybody else for that matter."
10. Howlin Wolf - Spoonful (0’55” – 1’05”)
from Howlin Wolf - Spoonful/ Howlin' for My Darling (1960)
“I got really into the blues for a while as a teenager, and the sheer rawness of the sound was a much needed counter to all the Haydn and Mozart I was having to learn at the time. A horrific fact I learned this week is that five of the top ten blues albums today are attributed to AI-generated acts. It feels like just the latest dark twist of the colonial/racist knife. Around 0:55 in this piece, you hear the hook. Just two notes! And after he sings it, we hear him play it on the guitar. Two motherfucking notes. And the way he drags the timing is exquisite. And the recording, with the valve distortion. Everything crystallises into this perfect moment of absolute clarity of purpose, idea and form."
11. The cast from La ola (The Wave) - La Voz Es Viento (3’47” – 3’57”)
from Matthew Herbert - La Ola OST (2025)
“It feels a bit grim to pick a piece of music one co-wrote, but one of my best friends, Sebastián Lelio, who directed this film, died suddenly recently, and music was such an essential part of his life that I wanted to acknowledge him here.
I also wanted to take a moment to draw people's attention to the incredible technique of Hugh Brunt's arrangement. If you listen to the flourish, he's asked the flute and clarinet to play the same line at the same time (as I'd written it), doubling the harp, but he's marked the dynamics so that the flute starts the phrase louder and gets quieter through the line, while the clarinet goes in the opposite direction, starting the phrase quieter and getting louder. It's such an extraordinary effect in terms of how it shifts both the texture and dynamics whilst leaving the original figure and its intentions intact. It's a tiny moment in one song in a huge film, but I have so much love and respect for arranger/orchestrators (he's also a composer) like Hugh, who take something flatly written on a computer and render it in 3D for players to perform, proposing something so much richer and better than I'd written, and rarely getting credit for it. It's a perfect detail."




















Comments